: Civilization and Its Discontents (): Sigmund Freud, James Strachey, Christopher Hitchens, Peter Gay: Books. Penguin’s new edition of Sigmund Freud’s essential Civilization and its Discontents is slim enough to be carried at all times, says Nicholas. Civilization and Its Discontents. By. SIGMUND FREUD . senses, the man in love declares that he and his beloved are one, and is prepared to behave as if it.
|Published (Last):||1 September 2009|
|PDF File Size:||14.63 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||17.29 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Alas, the spell is broken: The guilty conscience is the price paid by the individual to belong to eiscontents society, but often this guilt is left unconscious and is experienced as anxiety or ‘discontent’. Not only because it has hitherto not been easy to get hold of a copy, but because it quite simply tells you all you really need to know about life and its vicissitudes.
Here is a very classy new imprint from Penguin: His theories seem too speculative at times, but his insights on basic human psychology are enlightening.
Civilization and Its Discontents by Sigmund Freud
Motor power places gigantic forces at his disposal, which, like his muscles, he can employ in any direction; thanks to ships and aircraft neither water nor air can hinder his movements; by means of spectacles he corrects defects in the lens of his own eye; by means of the telescope he sees into the far distance; and by means of the microscope he overcomes the limit of visibility set by the structure of his retina. It is a version of Enlightenment thinking that has limited faith in the goodness of human nature in a Darwinist world – everything is subject to the powers of reasoned analysis and observation, but what people say and believe about themself must not be taken at face value – just look at the self-destructiveness we see in figures in public and private life.
As a rule this cruel aggressiveness waits for some provocation or puts itself at the service of some other purpose, whose goal might also have been reached by milder measures.
The main weakness of this book is its desultory style. Unconscious processes motivate much of our behaviour, and sex plays an important role.
Nov 11, Jessica rated it really liked it Recommends it for: I think Bloom is brilliantly on to something when he affirms that Freud wasn’t really a psychologist, consider that more of a literary conceit, what he really was was a philosopher, a wisdom writer.
Kindling the fire of knowledge
And the failures become greater and greater, and the culture gets angrier and angrier at all the failures, and demands more, and internalises more and more and the cultural super-ego gets stronger and harsher and more aggressive.
The Future of an Illusion. If we were to remove this factor, too, by allowing complete freedom of sexual life and thus abolishing the family, the germ-cell of civilization, we cannot, it is true, easily foresee what new paths the development of civilization could take; but one thing we can expect, and that is that this indestructible feature of human nature will follow at there.
I would add that one of those things that civilization tries to repress is violence, including violence against those women who are reduced to sex objects. But perhaps we may also familiarize ourselves with the idea that there are difficulties attaching to the nature of civilization which will not yield to any attempt at reform.
In spite of the incompleteness, I will venture on a few remarks as a conclusion to our enquiry.
I heard once that scientists have started to think of the psyche as more like the British Parliament- contending constituencies which have more on the table than just a-fuckin’ and a-fightin’. I read it because of course its a seminal classic and one of his central texts but was mildly disappointed to see that there wasn’t all that much “there” there. After graduating, he worked at the Vienna General Hospital.
And when his aggression at these demands on ite get too much, he internalises them through the form of punishment In frrud fourth chapter, Freud attempts a conjecture on the developmental history of civilization, which he supposes coincided with man learning to stand upright. It is a superficial masterpiece that stretches further than any of his other works; he is reaching for an explanation for human nature in terms of the id-ego-superego structure of the individual as he exists in civilization.
It is hard to tell here if that is his personal view, or he is guessing about attitudes in primitive society like towards the fireor if it reflects what he learned from his male patients. Some of those who have asked it have added that if it should turn out that life has no purpose, it would lose all value for them.
To these gods he attributed everything that seemed unattainable to his wishes, or that was forbidden to him. In that primal period of civilization, the contrast between a minority who enjoyed the advantages of civilization and a majority who were robbed of those advantages was, therefore, carried to extremes. Freud had been civvilisation with cancer of the jaw inand underwent more than 30 operations. And in this book, repression is an essential part of civilization. Aug 05, Michael rated it liked it Recommends it for: It’s totally void of meaning and I think the DSM V doesn’t use it at all as a category for that reason.
Long ago he formed an ideal conception of omnipotence and omniscience which he embodied in his gods. That he influenced the Modernist movement, especially regarding some famous techniques such as introspection, psychological analysis, stream of consciousness, involuntary memory and so on. And in Freud’s case, the track was pointing in an important direction: Many of the translations were done by Strachey himself; the rest were prepared under his supervision.
View all 9 comments. All else follows from this; and this is why, even at a time of unprecedented technological mastery, people are still no happier than they ever were. Freud used this horrific imagery to posit that all religious thought is based upon perversity and hatred. As regards the primitive peoples discontente exists to-day, careful researches have aand that their instinctual life is by no means to be envied for its freedom.
Nonetheless, he remains one of the most influential thinkers of the 20th century. While this analogy seems viable when thinking about sexual desire or hunger, it is useless when thinking of questions like language acquisition.
But I shall avoid the temptation of civilisatino upon a critique of American civilization; I do not wish to give an impression of wanting myself to employ American methods. How many pages are in this book?
Civilization and Its Discontents
May 14, Brian rated it really liked it Recommends it for: But hardly anything more. The result is a pervasive and familiar guilt. You can’t really make a workable model of human personality with his building blocks any more, can you? Underneath this is also an underlying argument that it is civilization itself which freuf the death-drive and the existence of neuroses, again a common enough idea.