with Homi K. Bhabha, a leading figure in contemporary cultural discourse, The concept of the third space is submitted as useful for analysing the enunciation. Homi Bhabha’s Third Space and African identity but as enunciation. . Homi Bhabha theorizes the Third Space of confusion and paradox, or liminality, within . The principal theoretical frame departs from Homi Bhabha’s () concepts of ‘ the third space of enunciation’ and ‘mocking mimicry’, which serve as a more.
|Published (Last):||26 August 2015|
|PDF File Size:||17.5 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||4.96 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
It is that Third Space, though unrepresentable in itself, which constitutes the discursive conditions of enunciation that ensure that the meaning and symbols of culture have no primordial unity or fixity; that even the same signs can be appropriated, translated, rehistoricized, and read anew.
Cultural Diversity and Cultural Differences | Homi K. Bhabha
Both the provinces and the empire experienced a number of changes, which cannot be formulated in terms of hybridisation, syncretism or acculturation cf.
The criticism is true to some extent: For instance, the later administration of the English and their missionaries in the same area created a very different situation which by no means was built on mediation cf. Instead, we find clusters of interwoven fibres, that is, practices or material patterns, of varying extent in time and space that may coincide with an ethnic group, but we should not be surprised if this way of looking at social practice turns out as something that crisscrosses assumed cultural units, regions or ethnicities.
These observations and insights are the result of empirical observations recognised by many anthropologists, but seem in general to have surpassed most archaeologists. The material dimension is not to be forgotten here.
It is thus apparent that Bhabha’s reasoning as well as postcolonial theory in generalnot only are of interest for grand scale periods of colonisation Mediterranean and historical. Cambridge University Press Barth, Fredrik Bhabha’s theoretical basis departs from a general poststructuralist stance Lacan, Derrida and Foucault whose legacy bhhabha develops via Franz Fanon and Edward Said in his deconstruction of colonial texts e.
Besides the notion of hybridity, it is also evident that Bhabha’s concept of third space of enunciation is interesting to pursue in archaeological analysis. The contact situation of the upper himi is, however, only one example of a colonial encounter with its own social and material circumstances.
She describes the strategy of a Czech Jew at Treblinka who applied a kind of mimicry in order to survive the holocaust. It is not a situation only restricted to confrontations between different individuals and groups, but also concerns encounters between individuals and materialities. Writers, such as Homi Bhabha and Salman Rushdie, who proceed from a consideration of the nature of postcolonial societies and the types of hybridization these various cultures have produced, proposed a radical rethinking—an appropriation of the European thinking by a different discourse.
Third Space Theory
In this case, the mimicry is hierarchically reversed as the middle-class teens imitate a lower-class life-style without themselves being subaltern. The concept of mimicry also applies on a material level.
Sahlins’ original argument, that the Hawaiians understood the appearance of Cook from a mythological point of view, is dismissed by Obeyesekere as a naive Eurocentric and colonial stereotyped idea of the mythical savage.
But, we do need to come to terms with the fact that our most familiar entities of prehistory Bell-Beakers, Greeks, and Vikings etc also were caught in processes of hybridity.
Tag: third space of enunciation
In his dialogism thidd, Mikhail Bakhtin emphasizes a space of enunciation where negotiation of discursive doubleness gives birth to a new speech act: The fluidity of rock art.
But in order to avoid simplistic arguments of the importance of specific individuals or generalising models of anonymous acculturation, diffusion, invasion, or exchange, the analytic field of encounters need to be adhered from a more varied and complex perspective. As I will try to show further on, such gross generalisations of the complexity and many faceted effects of encounters does seldom account for anything at all – except as examples of western mythmaking of the Other Obeyesekere Most such alterations are just temporary, but in conjunction with others, they can result in an important social change of the bhabhz term in a similar sense as formulated in Giddens’ theory of o or Braudel’s discussion of the event, the short- and the long term.
To Bhabha, social groups and bhabah have no or little essence but are mainly effects of expressions of power and certain discourses. But instead of simply viewing similarities as an indication of diffusion, exchange or acculturation, we may be able to identify more complex processes of mimicry.
It rejoices in mongrelization and fears the absolutism of the Pure. Chapter Two 41 Stein, Gil ed The knapped spear points manufactured using broken glass bottles and ceramics look similar to traditional Aboriginal stone artefacts, but are of little practical use Harrison The case concerns a situation that occurred in Januarywhen the British decided to finally occupy Zululand in the south of Africa.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: The third space of enunciation is employed as a metaphor for the ambiguous virtual field that emerges when two bhabh more individuals interact.
Bill Thompson offers an opposite conceptualisation of Third Space as public, civic space in the built environment under pressure from shopping malls and corporate sppace, transforming public space into an extension of the market. bhxbha
Applying ‘third space theory’ to nursery-aged children’s constructions of themselves as readers”. Instead, Bhabha argues, social encounters result in contradictory and ambivalent spaces in which social identities and ideologies are questioned and negotiated. Third Space Theory suggests that policies of remediation based in models of the Other are likely to be inadequate.
In order to move from the first to the second floor or vice versa, one needs to use the stairs. We should not expect to find similar developments in other encounter situations. Bhabha employs the concept for the effects that occur in any situation of encounters, which have more or less significant consequences.
They all have developed in relation to a larger context and therefore consist of elements of different origins which they to a varying extent have in common. Postcolonial studies cover a great variety of approaches outlined in the works of e.
It is rather a practice that involves both mockery and resistance. Towards a history of the vanishing present. Cultural difference has to be acknowledged: The beginning of the fight was a mere massacre; despite their overwhelming numbers the Zulus were gunned down in great speed by the English army. Entangled Objects and Hybrid Practices.
Somewhat contrary to Spivak, Bhabha thus allows the subaltern a voice Bhabha It is certainly true that social collectives are to some extent disordered by conflicting ideas, multiple voices, and interpretations, but as Barth argues, we should nonetheless expect to find: The recent approaches show that the power of postcolonial theory lies in its comparative methodology and the hybridized and syncretic view of the modern world which it implies.
They merged them into something quite different from the Algonquian, Iroquoian, and French cultures that gave them birth White Colonialism and archaeology in the Mediterranean. The Archaeology of Colonial Encounters Stein ed.
third space of enunciation – AltExploit
The origin of the emergence of new practices, materials or artefacts in an area is often a question to pursue, and even sometimes regarded as the main objective of the analysis. The ceramics were certainly not just dumped upon the Etruscans Osbourne suggests that the example reveals an active and creative element in the manner which the indigenous peoples of Etruria appropriated Greek mythology Osbourne The enunciation of cultural difference problematizes the division of past and present, tradition and modernity, at the level of cultural representation and its authoritative address.
Indiana university press, pp. Post was not sent – check your email addresses!